O media voyeurs, the name Elizabeth
Spiers inspires awe. Ms. Spiers is the original "Gawker" - the
founding editor of New York's most popular gossip blog, the pioneer
of the site's dark obsession with New York media, and the exemplar
of the snarky tone that bloggers the world over try to imitate.
Now, after a foray into the print world at New York magazine, Ms.
Spiers, a wry Alabamian, is returning to online gossip. In October
she took a job at Mediabistro.com where, among other things, she will
start up a media gossip blog called FishBowlNY and serve as its
co-author. Among her chief rivals is Gawker.com itself, which is now edited by a cheerful
24-year-old named Jessica Coen and is still a daily addiction for
the gossip hungry and media elite.
The face-off begins tomorrow when Mediabistro, largely a
journalist networking site, unveils FishBowlNY and several other new
blogs. The rivalry falls squarely into the grand New York tradition
of competing for the juiciest bits of gossip. This being the new
millennium, the battle is being raged not in screaming tabloids but
in cyberspace.
But Ms. Spiers's nemesis at Gawker is not without resources. Ms.
Coen earned her gossip wings just weeks after being snatched out of
Columbia Journalism School's class of 2005, scooping other blogs and
traditional media alike. And Gawker's readership, which has been
steadily growing, now numbers a million a month.
Though Ms. Coen is not personally obsessed with gossip, she knows
its power. "When Tara Reid's breasts fall down, I'm not like, 'Oh,
thank God!' " she said. "But it's the kind of thing that once it
goes up on Gawker, it's a record-setting day of traffic."
As the two blogs prepare to compete, they clearly mean business.
"I hope we do it better, we scoop them, and we post first," Ms.
Spiers said.
Nick Denton, the entrepreneur behind Gawker and its sister sites,
dismissed the competition. "I'd be more worried if a no-name site
run by a no-name journalist suddenly emerged," he said, "much in the
way that Gawker did two years ago."
As in many such rivalries, the barbs can get personal. Laurel
Touby, Mediabistro's founder, has been a frequent target of Gawker's
slings and arrows. When a departing Mediabistro editor neglected to
invite Ms. Touby to his farewell party, Ms. Coen reprinted an e-mail
message to the staff from Ms. Touby in which the snubbed
cyberhostess fumed, "I have to insist that you not attend this farce
of a party."
And two months before Ms. Touby's wedding, Gawker noticed that
she had forgotten to deactivate her personal profile on JDate, the
Jewish singles site, and linked to it, snarking, "Now we know how to
snare a new media goddess."
Such comments come with the territory, of course. It was none
other than Ms. Spiers who said that "class warfare as recreational
sport" was one of Gawker's main topics of interest, and she had a
willing audience in the many young members of the media who felt
they were slaving away to enrich the upper echelons at Condé Nast
and other companies. Thanks to Gawker, Condé Nasties finally fight
back, sending anonymous tips about what Anna Wintour said in the
elevator or whether Graydon Carter was or wasn't on the list at a
nightclub. Never mind accountability; it was the Web.
In this kind of sparring, turnabout is fair play. Just weeks
after Ms. Spiers's hiring at Mediabistro, Gawker poked fun at the
tone she took in another clash of the classes. Responding to
complaints that Mediabistro publishes freelancers' essays without
paying them, Ms. Spiers wrote: "These things are pretty
straightforward economic issues. If what we're supplying isn't
sufficient to meet what you're demanding, then obviously, you're not
buying. ... I don't walk by a Mercedes dealership and complain that
the prices are exploitative; I just don't buy it."
A bulletproof point, but to some freelancers her market-forces
rationale made her sound like one of the media overlords she'd once
zealously skewered. One freelancer responded: "Let me explain in
simpler terms what Elizabeth is saying. ... Newbie writers are
essentially like illegal immigrants, or mine workers in pre-union
times, or underage children in third world sweatshops. It's fair to
exploit them because they are willing to be exploited." Gawker
quickly reprinted excerpts and awarded Ms. Spiers an ironic "gold
medal for bravery."
But if verbal jousting plays a role in the rivalry that starts
tomorrow, at least the two companies will not compete on every
front. While Ms. Spiers's blog is focused solely on New York media,
Gawker offers celebrity sightings, entertainment tips and gleeful
dispatches about the likes of Paris Hilton and the Olsen twins.
"We're not going to be covering Brad and Jen," Ms. Touby said.
"Though we may cover the coverage."
And in Ms. Spiers's eyes, it is not just a two-blog fight. "Our
competition for this New York media blog is partially Gawker, but
it's also hugely the trades, Romenesko, and anybody who does media
reporting."
Moreover, data from other blog rivalries suggest that both
combatants may win. "One of the few infinitely renewable resources
seems to be Americans' attraction to gossip," said Dan Gillmor, a
columnist who specializes in the media. "And media people can't get
enough of gossip about ourselves."
But even if her new blog doesn't make money, Ms. Touby sees
another possible benefit. "They pick on me all the time," she said
of Gawker. "After this, they won't want to give us any more press at
all."